About us

Learn how Cayuga Creamery brings farmstead cheese and local food traditions to Ithaca, NY.

Cheese Made Close to Home

Cheese Made Close to Home

Cayuga Creamery connects Ithaca shoppers with the character of farmstead cheese: cheeses made on farms from milk produced there. Each cheese reflects its milk, make, and aging process, giving customers a chance to explore distinct textures and flavors. Ask for guidance on choosing a cheese for a meal, a board, or a thoughtful gift.

Good cheese is best enjoyed with a little context. At Cayuga Creamery, shoppers can learn what sets a cheese apart, how to store it, and when to serve it. Whether you’re planning a tasting or choosing one cheese for tonight’s table, clear details make it easier to find a selection that suits your needs.

Plan Your Cheese Selection

Tell us what you’re serving or celebrating, and get help choosing cheeses and accompaniments.